Skip to content

Apply term ownership to NLDI, NGWMN, and WQP prose #408

Description

@thodson-usgs

Parent

#406

Ownership rule

ADR 0013 separates package-owned core vocabulary from service-owned domain vocabulary:

  • getter is a dataretrieval core term. It applies only to public functions returning (DataFrame, metadata) and binds package prose and tests.
  • collection is a domain concept. Adapter prose should accurately translate the service's own vocabulary, while public parameters and wire spellings remain native to that service.

Primary sources settle the three adapters differently:

  • NLDI's official documentation calls its operations navigation functions. The Python adapter returns GeoDataFrames or JSON directly, without a metadata tuple, so calling these functions getters is a package vocabulary defect.
  • NGWMN's live OGC collections document publishes sites, providers, waterLevelObs, and the other record sets as collections. Prose calling those collection identifiers services is upstream-inaccurate; NGWMN itself remains the service.
  • WQP's official Web Services Guide calls these endpoints the Station Web Service, Result Service, and profile services. dataProfile is a separate request parameter. WQP's public service vocabulary is therefore native domain language and must not be normalized away.

What to build

Apply those ownership decisions consistently without changing public behavior:

  1. Describe NLDI's direct-return operations as navigation functions rather than getters, including package and test prose.
  2. Describe NGWMN OGC collection identifiers as collections in prose and comments, while continuing to call the external NGWMN system a service.
  3. Correct the shared glossary so it distinguishes WQP's Result/Station/Activity services from the separate dataProfile values.
  4. Preserve WQP's public service parameters, URL-builder documentation, exported names, wire paths, and other service-oriented public prose.

Acceptance criteria

  • NLDI prose and test comments no longer call direct GeoDataFrame or dictionary-returning functions getters.
  • NLDI is described as navigation functions, matching both its return contract and official API documentation.
  • NGWMN prose and comments use collection for identifiers exposed by its OGC /collections document.
  • References to the external NGWMN system continue to use service.
  • The glossary accurately records that WQP exposes Result, Station, and Activity services and treats dataProfile as a separate concept.
  • WQP's public service terminology and service-oriented URL-builder documentation remain unchanged.
  • Deprecated NWIS vocabulary, Samples resource/code-service terms, the deprecated CQL keyword, and permanent aliases remain unchanged.
  • No public name, signature, return shape, exported value, wire parameter, URL, or runtime behavior changes.
  • Documentation, offline adapter tests, lint, and architecture checks pass.

Blocked by

None — can start immediately.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    ready-for-agentFully specified and ready for an AFK agent

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions