Skip to content

Book credits: one per named presenter; reviewed ORCIDs for individual authors - #25

Draft
docxology wants to merge 5 commits into
mainfrom
feat/individual-credits-and-orcids
Draft

docxology wants to merge 5 commits into
mainfrom
feat/individual-credits-and-orcids

Conversation

@docxology

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

Summary

Version 3.3.0 deposited 51 credit labels as Zenodo creators. Joint talks were single entries ("Jesse Parent & Avery Lim"), and comma-separated labels put everything after the first comma in the given-name field. Jesse Parent asked (Nov 12) why he and Avery Lim were merged and why their ORCIDs were missing. The Zenodo metadata of 3.3.0 was corrected by hand the same day (56 individual creators; deposited files unchanged). This PR makes the next book version produce the same result from the pipeline instead of reverting the hand edit.

Changes

  • Individual cover credits (book_design.credit_names, prepare_book_design): each presenter label is split on commas and ampersands into the people it names, deduplicated by exact spelling, in contribution order after the Institute. No normalization or near-match merging ("Jes Parent" ≠ "Jesse Parent"). A split that would leave an empty part keeps the label whole. Each contribution's "Presenter:" line and the whole-label profile binding are unchanged.
  • Reviewed identifiers (load_credit_identifiers, CreditIdentifier, organize book --credit-identifiers PATH): an optional private JSON {"schema_version": 1, "people": [{"name", "orcid", "affiliation", "basis"}]}. ORCIDs must be bare iDs with a valid ISO 7064 check character; names must equal an individual cover credit; duplicates, padding, extra fields and URL-form iDs are refused. Values reach the Template author list (orcid, affiliation); basis is kept only in the private manifest receipt (design.author_identifiers).
  • Docs: organizer guide section on cover credits; a "Zenodo metadata edit after publication" section in docs/release_3_3_0.md; CHANGELOG; organizing AGENTS.md row.

Verification (local, Python 3.12, uv sync --locked --extra dev)

  • ./gate.sh test: 797 passed, 9 skipped; coverage 89.90% (gate 80%).
  • ./gate.sh lint, ./gate.sh docs, ./gate.sh program: pass.
  • New tests: tests/test_organizing_book_credits.py (18 cases); updated composite-credit expectations in test_organizing_book_design.py and test_organizing_cover_event.py.
  • Not run here: a native Template render (needs the Template checkout and its Python 3.14 environment). Before the next release, render and inspect the cover and the PDF/Word author metadata.

Not in this PR

  • No data refresh: data/public/2026 still carries contribution 36's submitted title ("From Minimal Regulators …"); the program now reads "From Minimal Model Systems to World Models: Boundary-Relative Distinctions for Factoring Generative Models". It comes in with the next snapshot.
  • No book render, tag, release or Zenodo version. Remote CI cannot run while Actions is locked by billing.

Merge only with the organizer's approval of the exact commit.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

https://claude.ai/code/session_018EQiJgP1guJjwwkBehJjDg

@docxology

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Presenter-credit and ORCID receipt audit (17 November 2026). Local qualification remains open for PR head 726aad4aa69b8a398e6093a8aaf8bec98e431dba against main a01cf0941f5397a5210c1eec5c95e196a939738a. This is still a conflicting draft. No fresh rebase, pytest, build, Template render, or hosted run is claimed; the earlier PR test results are historical, not results for a rebased candidate.

Both revisions contain the same published 2026 program snapshot, Git blob 07306edb5bc1db2dd8404c3c9ee2c9d5714c052d. Recomputing the separator and exact-name deduplication behavior yields 55 distinct presenter names and 56 creators including the Institute. This is a program-data check, not a render or identity-ownership check.

Program contribution Published label Individual credits
talk-79ba0396518881ec Dan Corva, Kevin Backhouse Dan Corva; Kevin Backhouse
talk-5529b456dc308ef2 Fraser Paterson, Andrew Pashea & Daniel Friedman Fraser Paterson; Andrew Pashea; Daniel Friedman
talk-414af3e53e96ece8 John Boik, Glen EP Ropella John Boik; Glen EP Ropella
talk-354181e0a9360578 Antonio Lucas-Alba & Héctor M. Manrique Antonio Lucas-Alba; Héctor M. Manrique
talk-2b1a7d1c34fd5092 Harshil Shah, Andrew Pashea Harshil Shah; Andrew Pashea
talk-926ae4cbac21b98d Harshil Shah, Satyaki Maitra Harshil Shah; Satyaki Maitra
talk-ebebeaad2bad66f7 Jesse Parent & Avery Lim Jesse Parent; Avery Lim
talk-a1b55a90a3543912 John H. Clippinger, Holly Grimm, Daniel Friedman John H. Clippinger; Holly Grimm; Daniel Friedman
talk-6f17ad5f124245f3 Michael Walker & Héctor M. Manrique Michael Walker; Héctor M. Manrique
ORCID evidence Receipt status
Jesse Parent No exact-name participant ORCID in the snapshot. The release note records written supply, but the organizer-reviewed receipt was unavailable to this audit. Jes Parent is not an exact-name match.
Avery Lim No exact-name participant ORCID in the snapshot. The same release note records written supply, but the organizer-reviewed receipt was unavailable to this audit.
Montijn van Loo The only credited name with a populated exact-name participant ORCID in the public snapshot; that field is not organizer approval for the next book.
Other 52 credited names No populated exact-name participant ORCID in the snapshot. That does not establish that the presenters lack ORCIDs.

Keep the draft unmerged until the organizer reviews the two receipts or explicitly waives their inclusion, the rebased candidate passes the local tests and build (including Template cover and PDF/Word author metadata inspection), and the organizer approves that exact commit. Keep private receipts out of the public thread.

docxology and others added 5 commits November 17, 2026 16:57
Split published presenter labels on commas and ampersands so each person is one cover credit and Template author, deduplicated by exact spelling. Add load_credit_identifiers and CreditIdentifier: an organizer-reviewed private JSON of ORCIDs (check character verified) and affiliations bound to exact individual credits and recorded in the design receipt.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_018EQiJgP1guJjwwkBehJjDg
The option requires the paired cover artwork and loads the file through the private-input boundary.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_018EQiJgP1guJjwwkBehJjDg
Composite labels now become one credit per person; ORCID admission refuses bad check characters, URL forms, duplicates, padding, extra fields and names that are not individual credits.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_018EQiJgP1guJjwwkBehJjDg
Describe the credit split and --credit-identifiers in the organizer guide, and record the November 12 hand edit of the version 3.3.0 Zenodo metadata (56 individual creators; ORCIDs for Jesse Parent and Avery Lim; deposited files unchanged).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_018EQiJgP1guJjwwkBehJjDg
@docxology
docxology force-pushed the feat/individual-credits-and-orcids branch from 726aad4 to 68700c3 Compare November 18, 2026 03:25
@docxology

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Local qualification for rebased head 68700c31f2211547225ea78dee397bd5f1166462 against main at a01cf0941f5397a5210c1eec5c95e196a939738a.

  • Ruff lint and format passed. All 45 focused book tests passed. GitVault execution event f34d0d7fab76c1818f78dee6994456c0ce518c5aae0515f5cfb5c4c1f43da2c7.
  • Template f89c4cf959d42854e09dfb46c2fdf3340b4dcdfd and CPython 3.14.10 produced a 60-page PDF and a DOCX from the committed 2026 program. I reviewed every PDF page at overview scale. The cover credits and the embedded PDF author and Word creator fields contain all 56 creators in the same order, beginning with the Institute.
  • PDF SHA-256 7b281d92107264943e043982e022a9a8e336665cce4f8bbb6a9ea598f09ca475. DOCX SHA-256 57ca75449a3b46ef305a8b77af11a02d5ffe5c2a24ff2d8cdb480f3d98b9c6a4.
  • The native renderer exited zero. The enclosing job flagged an error when the first verifier read the staging manifest. I verified the retained PDF and DOCX against the final render manifest and checked both file digests. GitVault render execution event db0176b130d06b662e9f0f8710e12ccc5206b58552aea3ec7569015c06042e08.

The verification used neutral artwork and no DOI or private ORCID receipts. The draft awaits organizer approval.

This branch has not been deployed

No deployments
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant