Skip to content

Document observation frames and public verification limits - #29

Draft
Riverbraid wants to merge 5 commits into
mainfrom
docs/observation-frame-audit-2026-11-01
Draft

Riverbraid wants to merge 5 commits into
mainfrom
docs/observation-frame-audit-2026-11-01

Conversation

@Riverbraid

@Riverbraid Riverbraid commented Nov 1, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Scope

Document the observation frames that can make a configured PASS seem broader than its evidence. Add a focused guide, clarify the Evaluation Kit verification-depth page, add the source-confirmed limitations, and link the guide from README.

Evidence

  • Public Core at b5c8cde0ebb56ac98bc738545a8e80c10c67b191: byte-audit.mjs swallows Git observation failures. An isolated non-Git fixture returned BYTE_GATE_PASS_VERIFIED with null branch/commit and zero tracked files. This reproduces a false-positive route in the public script, not a Riverbraid production result.
  • Public Evaluation Kit at cd814ac415d7952e524c8edd5c595d77189ed24d: four of 30 commands check README presence; external_reproduction derives only from zero failing commands; setup can exit before final JSON. The latter is source-path review, not an executed failure case.
  • Same-day Core correction draft #9 passed six focused CI cases. Its Ring 2 run #185 found 8/8 constellation verification but only 2/8 byte verification: six BOM findings and three repositories with previously skipped symlink/gitlink paths. The guide records the exact claim limit; the Core branch remains draft.
  • Public Documentation base 541d3f62f9e70e38f5ea4338d9799540f148469c; branch text was fetched and matched after the update.

Boundary

  • Documentation only
  • No code, runner, registry, expected-result, workflow, or authority-state change
  • No new 30-repository, native, or founder-local execution claim

The Core script repair is separately proposed in draft PR #9. Kit runner changes would need their own selected code change and evidence. This draft is for review; it does not assert adoption or qualification.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant