Repository navigation
Prepare v5.0.0 server compatibility - #18
Conversation
valzargaming
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Completed Codex source review of exact head 3cfd4b9 against main 821afe1.
No blocking source defect found in the reviewed engine-aware lifecycle routing, async message/panel/HTTP caller settlement, IPC framing and list-file metadata preservation, durable relay checkpoints/replay limits, configuration/dependency migration, development-version/API provenance and source tooling. The latest integration is a conflict-free merge of already merged #15. A separate source-only comparison of both parents found no regression in safehouse/v5 Slash coexistence, options defaults or native controls. Safehouse and directory remain disabled without explicit configuration.
Exact-head evidence was checked through workflow records and actual job steps: PHP 8.3–8.5 supervision/consumer/IPC/relay fixtures (https://github.com/Valgorithms/Civilizationbot/actions/runs/39874721044); Windows/Linux portable contracts, including all three Windows IPC/list and relay steps (https://github.com/Valgorithms/Civilizationbot/actions/runs/39874721157); combined safehouse spool/economics and injected Discord/schema fixtures (https://github.com/Valgorithms/Civilizationbot/actions/runs/39874721098); read-only API build/links/search/exact-source development provenance (https://github.com/Valgorithms/Civilizationbot/actions/runs/39874721029); locked-dependency, source MCP and heartbeat lanes. All 58 substantive check records are completed/success. The one publication job was skipped and supplies no publication acceptance. The only new local execution was syntax/whitespace checking; no broad local suite, install, game or bot ran.
Limits: this COMMENT records the completed Codex source review, not an independent maintainer APPROVE event. List updates preserve existing file access metadata but are in-place: native readers may observe partial contents and rejection does not promise rollback. Relay delivery is at least once; host power-loss guarantees and installation-specific cutover remain unaccepted. Real native/OpenDream lifecycle/Topic/player readiness, actual game IPC application/Discord delivery, registration, Pages publication and stable release remain separately authorized activation/release gates in docs/releases/v5.0.0.md. No runtime checkout, live Gaia, bot/game controls, credentials, production data or consumed test reservation changed.
Behavior
Prepares v5 development source across engine-aware lifecycle routing, bounded LF file IPC, durable relay checkpoints, awaited list/unban writes, webhook delivery and source tooling. Main
821afe15822b5ecf5417210854970661394a0682, including merged #15 and #20, is integrated.5.0.0-dev, verifies source-derived API provenance and documents configuration/dependency/checkpoint migration and durability limits. Publication remains separate.Verification
Final source head:
3cfd4b9e47891179e3c632af63c5305881f5dd45.PHP 8.3/8.4/8.5 supervision and Windows/Linux replica contracts: passed, including actual restart/lifecycle/admin-list callers, IPC/list, relay, injected delivery, webhook and unban steps.
Windows/Linux PHP 8.3–8.5 portable contracts: passed; the three Windows jobs actually ran both newly added IPC/list and durable-relay steps.
Read-only API documentation: passed, including pinned phpDocumentor build, links/search and matching exact-source development provenance. This lane cannot publish.
Locked dependency/lint contracts, source MCP protocol tests, and heartbeat contracts: passed. See Checks for the complete push/PR job set.
Latest local PHP syntax and whitespace checks passed. Scoped independent source/migration review found no blocking defect. No heavy local suite, install, compilation or native test ran. Docs publication was skipped and is not a publication pass.
Combined safehouse spool/economics and injected Discord/schema contracts: passed after integrating merged Integrate disabled Discord safehouse routing and authenticated spool #15. Source comparison of both parents found no conflict or options/command-route regression.
Final source review and later release
Completed exact-head Codex source review is recorded as a COMMENT review, with evidence and limits. This is not an independent maintainer APPROVE event. The normal merge completed as
d276e97dc8b9bea1b86226c4dfbe485d71e43af5.The ledger in
docs/releases/v5.0.0.mdseparates reviewed source migration/durability from installation cutover and stable release. It supplies bounded offline follow-up commands and resource/effect limits. Real native/OpenDream lifecycle, Topic/player readiness, five game IPC consumers and actual Discord delivery remain unaccepted. They require an owner-supplied existing harness, isolated fixture/ports and separately coordinated approval; they remain activation/release gates, and source review does not authorize them. Installation-specific migration approval, fresh authorized Pages publication/readback and stable tagging remain later gates.No official registration, runtime checkout update, bot/game control, deployment, credentials, production data or consumed test-reservation change occurred. OpenDream remains paused.
Final combined-head CI: all 58 substantive check records are completed/success; the separate publication job is completed/skipped. No pending or failed records remained before merge. Publication is not established by that skipped job.