Skip to content

Records and docs from the low-CPU run: triage, fidelity reviews, docs currency, brief study - #1134

Open
REPPL wants to merge 17 commits into
mainfrom
land/lowcpu-run-2026-10-25
Open

REPPL wants to merge 17 commits into
mainfrom
land/lowcpu-run-2026-10-25

Conversation

@REPPL

@REPPL REPPL commented Oct 26, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

Records and docs from the 2026-10-24/25 low-CPU run, landed as one branch so the shared machine runs one preflight instead of four. The branch adds no Go code: it carries issue records, intent audit notes and docs/ prose.

What it lands

  • Hand-back triage. Remedies for the four hand-back issues the drain listed as ineligible for want of one, the 20 defects the triage readers met outside the records they triaged (each filed with a remedy), and one stale coordination record resolved.
  • Owed fidelity reviews. 17 of the 21 owed reviews are recorded in their intents' Audit Notes, each ingested from an intent-auditor run on origin/main. No criterion came back not met; the one inconclusive criterion was struck by a later decision, and that audit defect is filed. The other 4 are left for the session that handles security-class work.
  • Docs currency. 16 prose fixes in docs/, each checked against the code, and 47 records for what a prose edit cannot fix: the generated CLI reference is fixed in the Go help text, and the root README is another session's file, so its findings are recorded, not edited.
  • Brief single-source study. 105 records of conflicting or stale passages in the brief, most of them a second copy of a verb's behaviour that has drifted from its command page or the code. Two records the tree already satisfies are resolved.
  • Leftovers of the run. 21 records: side findings from the triage's state-of-the-art passes, and promises the fidelity reviews' gap audits found unbuilt or unproven.

Not in this pull request

  • The cross-document consistency pass is still running and lands separately, from a branch held at the commit its corpus was read from.
  • The study's main ruling, which file is the single home of a verb's behaviour, is owed to the product thinker.

Checks

make preflight passed on this branch's tip, run through the load gate.

Assisted-by: Claude:claude-opus-5-5

REPPL added 16 commits October 24, 2026 16:24
The drain lists these four as ineligible because they carry no remedy, so
no lane can take them and the board cannot say what would close them.
Each now carries one, checked against the tree at origin/main.

The forge allocator and the title ceiling keep their open rulings (J12,
and the ceiling's unit and value): their remedies open "Waits on" and
name the fix for each answer, so the drain still hands them back. The
reach baseline and the lint docs JSON shape need no ruling.

Refs: iss-2608210737264758, iss-2609020721396212, iss-2609252211487887, iss-2610100649471088
Assisted-by: Claude:claude-opus-5-5
Each intent's Audit Notes now carries its review verdict, ingested from
an intent-auditor run on origin/main:

- itd-3: 2 met, 2 met with concerns, 2 not met (ac-5, ac-6)
- itd-6: 3 met, 1 inconclusive (ac-1)
- itd-24: 3 met, 3 met with concerns, 2 not met (ac-2, ac-7)

The ingest captured one issue per intent for the check still owed. Two
defects the run met are captured too: reserve refuses a shipped intent,
so an owed review cannot be reserved, and the auditor's output rule
describes a fail-closed fence the file ingest does not have.

Refs: iss-2610241427397332, iss-2610241426406882, iss-2610241431221889, iss-2610241430042742, iss-2610241430326301
Assisted-by: Claude:claude-opus-5-5
…65 and itd-2609151138388536

Each intent's Audit Notes now carries its review verdict, ingested from
an intent-auditor run on origin/main:

- itd-201: 3 met, 7 met with concerns; conditions 2 narrowed, 1 untested
- itd-2609091034175565: 52 met, 1 met with concerns; conditions 9
  survived, 3 narrowed, 1 untested
- itd-2609151138388536: 6 met, 2 met with concerns; 4 conditions survived

No criterion is not met or inconclusive, so no check is left owed.

Assisted-by: Claude:claude-opus-5-5
Each intent's Audit Notes now carries its review verdict, ingested from
an intent-auditor run on origin/main:

- itd-2609212103568351 (the status block): 1 met, 4 met with concerns
- itd-2609212103572513 (release targets): 3 met, 1 met with concerns
- itd-2610030720038073 (the home folder's name): 3 met, 2 met with
  concerns, 1 not met (ac-6: the indexing receipt measured a probe
  folder outside the home, and the run-log check was never taken)

The ingest captured iss-2610241551259104 for the check ac-6 leaves owed.

Refs: iss-2610241551259104
Assisted-by: Claude:claude-opus-5-5
…d-2610090831227812

Each intent's Audit Notes now carries its review verdict, ingested from
an intent-auditor run on origin/main:

- itd-2610030810350727 (the question layout): 4 met, 6 met with
  concerns, 1 inconclusive (ac-6, a criterion the intent struck)
- itd-2610090831227812 (the person's command menu): 6 met, 6 met with
  concerns

The ingest captured iss-2610241604049754 for the check ac-6 leaves owed.

Refs: iss-2610241604049754
Assisted-by: Claude:claude-opus-5-5
…on sweep

The triage readers confirmed defects outside the records they were
triaging; each is filed with a remedy, one record per finding (the twelve
duplicated decision records, found by four batches, are one). Also filed:
the SessionEnd hook the host still cancels on a loaded machine, reported
by the person with the remedy they chose, and the plugin catalogue's
description, which differs from the manifest's.

The coordination sweep record is resolved: the research note committed
in 019a6c5 answers its four questions, and the intent it was owed to
has since been superseded by a shipped one.

Resolves: iss-2608230943533581
Refs: iss-2610241519088123, iss-2610241549052683, iss-2610241549107888, iss-2610241549164432, iss-2610241549220956, iss-2610241549275970, iss-2610241549334990, iss-2610241549396753, iss-2610241549433260, iss-2610241549487283, iss-2610241549531180, iss-2610241549584964, iss-2610241550026188, iss-2610241550073708, iss-2610241550119108, iss-2610241550154898, iss-2610241550202749, iss-2610241550257430, iss-2610241550303964, iss-2610241606415232
Assisted-by: Claude:claude-opus-5-5
The intent's Audit Notes now carries its review verdict, ingested from an
intent-auditor run on origin/main: 4 met, 8 met with concerns, 1 not met
(ac-13: the live walk's receipt was never attached to the pull request).

The ingest captured iss-2610241613191748 for the check ac-13 leaves owed.

Refs: iss-2610241613191748
Assisted-by: Claude:claude-opus-5-5
Each fix is the smallest edit that makes a page match the code:

- install: the name-guard hooks run abcd only where a clone opts in, and
  the Stop, StopFailure and SubagentStop hooks download nothing either
- upgrade to v0.14.0: the launch preview exits 0 whatever it finds and
  fails only when it cannot run
- roles: a fresh install starts with a person as facilitator
  (adr-2610150603484802), and the register setting is a design target
- terminology: the implement loop is abcd's own, the pacing intent and an
  MCP server ship, and itd-33 is superseded by the shipped reservation
- writing-style: name the persona_registry and retired-role-word rules
- reference index: list the pages the folder actually holds

Assisted-by: Claude:claude-opus-5-5
…6-10-16

Each intent's Audit Notes now carries its review verdict, ingested from
an intent-auditor run on origin/main:

- itd-2610161016391855 (a stuck drain lane hands itself back): 8 met,
  3 met with concerns
- itd-2610161016394967 (several people's drains share the work): 13 met,
  7 met with concerns
- itd-2610161016401115 (a drain runs unattended on a hosted session):
  6 met, 5 met with concerns
- itd-2610161616086564 (after a plugin update abcd offers setup): 7 met,
  3 met with concerns

No criterion is not met or inconclusive, so no check is left owed.

Assisted-by: Claude:claude-opus-5-5
The docs-currency review of docs/ and the root README checked 558
claims. Sixteen were fixed on this branch. These 47 records hold the
rest:

- 30 from the install, how-to, explanation and reference pages, and
  from the first two parts of the generated CLI reference (readers D1
  to D5)
- 12 from the last two parts of the CLI reference (readers D6 and D7).
  The page is generated from the Go help text, so each record names the
  help string to change rather than the page.
- 5 from the root README (reader D8). Another session is editing that
  file, so its findings are recorded here, not edited.

One more README finding is already held by an open record and was not
filed again. Security-class claims were counted and not reviewed.

Assisted-by: Claude:claude-opus-5-5
The intent's Audit Notes now carry its review verdict, ingested from an
intent-auditor run on origin/main. After a plugin update, abcd says what
changed and offers the setup the release brings: 4 criteria met and 4 met
with concerns. Of its four scope conditions, two survived and two
narrowed.

No criterion is not met or inconclusive, so no check is left owed. That
pays the last of the reviews this drain could take: 17 of the 21 owed are
recorded, and the other 4 are left for the session that handles
security-class work.

Assisted-by: Claude:claude-opus-5-5
One landing for three record-and-docs branches from the 2026-10-24 low-CPU
run, so the crowded machine runs one preflight instead of three:

- triage/handback-records: the hand-back triage's resolves and remedies
- audit/owed-fidelity-reviews: 17 owed fidelity reviews recorded
- docs/currency-2026-10-24: the docs-currency fixes and their captures

Assisted-by: Claude:claude-opus-5-5
Thirteen read-only readers classified every section of the brief against
the files that state the same thing: the command pages, docs/, the ADRs,
the principles, the intents and the code. Where a section conflicted
with its counterpart or with the code, or described machinery that has
since moved, the reader recorded a finding with the edit that fixes it.

These 105 records are those findings, one each. Most are a second copy of
a verb's behaviour that has drifted from the command page or the code,
which is the study's main result: the surface chapters and commands/
both state each verb's behaviour, and only the chapter is gated.

Eighteen findings were already held by open records and were not filed
again; one more turned out to duplicate an open record when it was filed,
and was dropped. Where the filing-time match linked a record to an
unrelated one, the link was removed; the seven links kept were checked.
Sections touching security were counted and not assessed.

Assisted-by: Claude:claude-opus-5-5
…eft open

Two sets of findings from this run that had no record yet.

Six came from the state-of-the-art passes run during the hand-back
triage, outside the records being triaged: two stale counts in the
rulesets README and the CI header, the kernel-format claim for the
Assisted-by trailer, a dated statement in a research note, a missing link
gate for the docs site, and the cloud connector's undocumented-answer
comment.

Fifteen came from the fidelity reviews' gap audits: promises the delivery
left unbuilt or unproven, each with the step that closes it. Three of the
reviews met the same unrecorded lab rerun, which is one record. One is a
defect in the audit itself: it judges acceptance criteria a later decision
struck, so the owed check such a criterion files can never clear.

Missing items an open record already holds were not filed again.

Assisted-by: Claude:claude-opus-5-5
The brief's single-source study found both asks already met on main:

- The memory-note glossary entry names /abcd:memory add as shipped. The
  record said no such verb existed; c8d1ab0 shipped it, so the entry is
  right as written.
- The configuration chapter's user-scope inventory now lists interviews/
  and backups/, added in a394eb1, which is what that record asked for.
  The other omissions the study found are held by an open record.

Resolves: iss-2610141705112796, iss-2610161332060895
Assisted-by: Claude:claude-opus-5-5
Two records quoted text that the renderer refuses outside a code span: a
README link to CITATION.cff, which does not resolve from the ledger, and two
paths with a placeholder in angle brackets, which read as inline HTML.
Both quotes now sit in code spans, so record-lint passes them and the
quoted text is unchanged.

Assisted-by: Claude:claude-opus-5-5
@REPPL
REPPL enabled auto-merge October 26, 2026 10:27
@REPPL
REPPL added this pull request to the merge queue Oct 26, 2026
@github-merge-queue
github-merge-queue Bot removed this pull request from the merge queue due to a conflict with the base branch Oct 26, 2026
Main moved while the landing waited in the queue. One conflict, in
docs/reference/terminology.md: this branch rewrote the Agent harness and
Agent loop rows, and main rewrote the Agent identity row. Each side's
rows are kept.

Assisted-by: Claude:claude-opus-5-5
@REPPL
REPPL enabled auto-merge October 26, 2026 14:54

This branch has not been deployed

No deployments
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant