Skip to content

CE9500 (feedback widget App ID) cannot be fixed headless: building blocks cannot be altered, and nothing reads the app ID #1886

Open

Description

@tgolembiewski

Environment

  • mxcli v0.32.0 (release binary, 2026-11-15), macOS arm64
  • Mendix 11.12.1 app, FeedbackModule 4.0.2, Atlas_Core 4.1.3

What happens

Studio Pro reports CE9500 "This feedback widget has an invalid App ID" on every feedback widget whose sprintrapp
value is 1 once the app has a Sprintr/Portal app ID. In an app created from an older template this includes the
building block FeedbackModule.FeedbackWidget as well as the snippet Atlas_Core.FeedbackWidget.

#1087 was closed with alter page ... { set sprintrapp = '<app-id>' on feedbackWidget1 }. That reaches pages and
snippets, but not building blocks:

$ mxcli check bb.mdl        # mdl 1; alter building block FeedbackModule.FeedbackWidget { ... };
line 2:6 no viable alternative at input 'alterbuilding'
$ mxcli -p W.mpr -c "describe building block FeedbackModule.FeedbackWidget"
-- Building blocks are read-only; they cannot be created via MDL.

So after the snippet is fixed, CE9500 remains on the building block.

What Studio Pro does (read from 11.12.1 / 11.16.0 assemblies)

  • The check is Mendix.Modeler.WebUI.Projects.FeedbackWidgetProjectCheck. It returns early in headless mode, so
    mx check never reports CE9500, CW9501 or CW9502. That explains why mxcli docker check stays silent.
  • The App ID is git config mendix.sprintr-project-id in the app folder
    (GitSprintrProjectInfoProvider). It is not stored in the .mpr.
  • The quick fix (FeedbackWidgetsProblemTaskProvider.UpdateAppIds) sets WidgetValue.PrimitiveValue of the
    property sprintrapp to that ID. It does this on every CustomWidget in the project (GetAllStorageObjects, so
    building blocks too) whose widget ID is SprintrFeedbackWidget.SprintrFeedback or
    com.mendix.widget.native.feedback.Feedback.

Proposal

Add mxcli fix feedback-app-id [-p app.mpr] [--app-id <id>]. By default it takes the ID from
git config mendix.sprintr-project-id, and with no ID it reports that and changes nothing. It should set
sprintrapp on all feedback widgets in every unit, building blocks included, and report the count per document.
mxcli docker check could also warn about the mismatch itself, since mx check cannot.

Checked against the 2026-11-17 nightly: nothing there changes this.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions