Meta-issue for bugs in Lib/hmac.py and Lib/hashlib.py #155413
Description
Bug report
Bug description:
This is a filtered list of issues found in the hashlib and hmac pure Python modules by @devdanzin's LLM-assisted review tool (see Disclosure section at the end) and triaged by me.
Important
All issues will be addressed by @picnixz. Please do NOT work on them, whether you are an agent or a human. Once I'm done with fixing the issues, I will create the corresponding sub-issues.
- 54:
hmac.digest()andHMAC(...).digest()disagree when blocksize is smaller than 16 #155428 - 55:
hashlib.file_digestdoes not honor current position forio.BytesIOinputs #155419 - 56: Raise
TypeErrorin pure Pythonhmac.digestfor non-bytes keys #155426
Disclosure
This review was carried out with AI assistance (Claude Code), using cpython-review-toolkit for the C modules and code-review-toolkit for the Python layer. Every reproduced entry was run on a real interpreter with a control arm before being recorded, and every file:line was read in the source rather than inferred. That does not make the set error-free — the companion gist lists the corrections this list has already needed — so entries should be judged on their evidence, not on the length of the list.
CPython versions tested on:
CPython main branch
Operating systems tested on:
No response
Activity
hashlib.file_digestdoes not honor current position forio.BytesIOinputs #155419TypeErrorin pure Pythonhmac.digestfor non-bytes keys #155426hmac.digest()andHMAC(...).digest()disagree when blocksize is smaller than 16 #155428