Skip to content

Prove L4 in full and A2 (Fate is a chain); recheck both in Rocq and core Lean - #122

Merged
hyperpolymath merged 3 commits into
claude/pwg-names-ladderfrom
claude/prove-l4-a2-full
Nov 17, 2026
Merged

hyperpolymath merged 3 commits into
claude/pwg-names-ladderfrom
claude/prove-l4-a2-full

Conversation

@hyperpolymath

@hyperpolymath hyperpolymath commented Nov 17, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Summary

The owner ruled on 2026-11-17 to prove, not narrow: L4 and A2 must be proved as their titles state them. This PR is stacked on #119, which splits L4 into four parts and A2 into two (ruling of 2026-11-16). It proves the parts #119 leaves ungraded (L4-bond-merge, L4-lifting, A2-chain), plus retention-order. It adds the repository's first Rocq leg and a Mathlib-free Lean leg for all seven rows. #119's branch is not edited.

Derived result (pwg-derive.sh, never hand-written): all seven rows reach PWG-2ii. They do not reach PWG-1, because the receipts are from run 44006871652 on d5234b1, not from the ledger's source commit.

Census of 28 theory obligations: PWG-3 15, PWG-2i 0, PWG-2ii 7, PWG-1 0, ungraded 6. The previous census, of the same 28, was PWG-3 18, ungraded 10.

⚠️ One owner decision this PR does not take

PROOF-STATUS records an owner ruling from 2026-11-09: "Lean is a generator, not a leg … no Lean row here is or will be a §2 recheck leg." That ruling gives the Mathlib dependency as its reason. The Lean leg added here imports nothing, and today's instruction says theory is "rechecked in Rocq and Lean". The leg is therefore recorded RECONCILED and counts, and the conflict is written into PROOF-STATUS (Recheck legs of the order laws and L4).

If the owner means the 2026-11-09 ruling to cover this leg too, flip its seven Lean state fields to BRIDGE-PENDING. The seven rows then derive PWG-2i. It is a one-field change per row.

Changes

  • Agda (normative, --safe --without-K --cubical-compatible):
    • TB/OrderLaws.agda: fateLte-{trans,antisym,total}, packaged as fate-isTotalOrder : IsTotalOrder _≡_ _≤F_ (A2-chain); dLte-isTotalOrder; and ⊑-trans, ⊑-dec, ⊑-isPreorder (retention-order).
    • TB/Monotone.agda: bondL4Mono{R,L} and mergeL4Mono{R,L} (L4-bond-merge); gradeL4Mono{R,L} and ▷-mono (L4-lifting). The left forms follow from the right forms by commutativity.
    • TB/Bridge.agda: see the bridge bullet below.
  • Rocq leg (verification/proofs/rocq/RatifiedOrder.v): Coq 8.18.0, no Require. It restates the carrier clause for clause and re-proves everything above.
  • Lean leg (verification/proofs/lean4/ratified-order/RatifiedOrder.lean): Lean 4.16.0. Core only, with no import and no simp, omega or decide.
  • Definition bridge:
    • Each leg proves six numeral-list tables by computation. They give the values of fateLte, ▷f, bondLte, ▷b, mergeLte and ▷m, and the literals are the same in all three provers.
    • Bond and Merge are covered exhaustively. Fate is covered on 9 points (81 pairs).
    • Measured: changing withheld ▷b intact to intact leaves every theorem provable in both legs. Only bridge_bcomp catches it.
  • Gate (scripts/check-recheck-legs.sh rocq|lean|controls):
    • Asserts the pinned prover version.
    • Runs an axiom audit over every declaration. It fails on any axiom and on an empty audit domain.
    • Runs six planted controls, and each must be caught. CI runs them in a new recheck-legs job.
  • Ledger and docs (commit 131a33c):
    • Three new receipts.
    • Agda legs become PROVEN for the four previously ungraded rows.
    • Rocq and Lean legs become RECONCILED on all seven rows.
    • PROOF-STATUS gets the derived table and census, the L4, A2 and retention rows, new census prose, and a full §2.2 correspondence record. README and CHANGELOG follow.

RSR Quality Checklist

Required

  • Tests pass: pwg-check.sh PASS (table and census match), test-gate-falsifiability.sh 29/29, tests/aspect_tests.sh PASS=3
  • Code is formatted; ledger JCS-canonical (jq -cS . | cmp)
  • Linter is clean: ShellCheck 0.11.0, SHA-256 matching quality.yml's pin, at --severity=style over all tracked *.sh
  • No banned language patterns (bash only)
  • No unsafe blocks without // SAFETY: comments
  • No banned functions (no Admitted, sorry or postulate)
  • SPDX license headers present on all new files
  • No secrets, credentials, or .env files included

As Applicable

  • Documentation updated: PROOF-STATUS, README
  • CHANGELOG updated

Testing

Kernel runs. CI run 44006871652 on d5234b1, with the same results reproduced locally:

Check Tool / version Command Exit Observed
Agda Agda 2.7.0.1, agda-stdlib v2.0 agda --safe --without-K --cubical-compatible All.agda ; … Smoke.agda 0 PASS: All.agda + Smoke.agda typecheck
Agda cone mathesis scan-postulates.sh over the 12 first-party modules of the 145-module cone 0 12 files, 0 postulate(s)
Rocq coqc 8.18.0 bash scripts/check-recheck-legs.sh rocq 0 closed under the global context for 49 of 49, file sha256 89085ae4…
Lean Lean 4.16.0 (128a1e6b0a82) bash scripts/check-recheck-legs.sh lean 0 axioms: none for 49 of 49 declared theorem(s), file sha256 74c33f13…
Controls both bash scripts/check-recheck-legs.sh controls 0 6 of 6 caught, each for its stated reason
Agda negative controls (local) Agda 2.7.0.1 an antitone bond lemma; antisymmetry concluding x ≡ present 42 / 42 rejected

Not established:

  • Completeness of the chain is not proved in any prover. Spec §7 uses it ("each coordinate is a complete chain"), but the A2 title does not claim it.
  • The L4Monotonicity.lean docstring that says "complete chain" (audit finding 12) is untouched.
  • The other 15 PWG-3 rows still owe both recheck legs.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

https://claude.ai/code/session_01J4QvDf73vaDJwGZ3qMSeH3

Owner ruling 2026-11-17: prove the full claims rather than narrow them.

TB/OrderLaws.agda (new):
- A2-chain: fateLte is transitive, antisymmetric and total, packaged
  as fate-isTotalOrder : IsTotalOrder _≡_ _≤F_ (standard library). The
  fidelity order is a chain too (dLte-isTotalOrder), and so is lteb.
- retention-order: ⊑ is transitive (⊑-trans) and decidable (⊑-dec);
  with TB.Order.⊑-refl that is ⊑-isPreorder.

TB/Monotone.agda (new):
- L4-bond-merge: bondL4Mono{R,L}, mergeL4Mono{R,L}.
- L4-lifting: gradeL4Mono{R,L} for the grade composition, and ▷-mono
  (both arguments at once, through ⊑-trans).
- Each left form follows from its right form by the coordinate's
  commutativity (▷b-comm, ▷m-comm, grade-comm).

No existing definition or theorem changes. All.agda and Smoke.agda pin
the new headlines.

Checked locally: Agda 2.7.0.1 (release binary, SHA-256 975b515a…),
agda-stdlib v2.0 (tag commit 2b8fff10), invocation
`agda --safe --without-K --cubical-compatible {All,Smoke}.agda`, exit 0
for both. Negative controls: an antitone bond lemma and an
antisymmetry concluding `x ≡ present` are each rejected (exit 42).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01J4QvDf73vaDJwGZ3qMSeH3
…itions

PROOF-POLICY §2: every Agda theory proof is rechecked in Rocq and Lean,
with no Mathlib. The existing Lean packages import Mathlib, so their
legs stay BRIDGE-PENDING. These two legs do not.

- verification/proofs/rocq/RatifiedOrder.v (new): Coq 8.18.0, no
  Require, no axiom. Restates TB.Grade/TB.Order clause for clause and
  re-proves L4 on every coordinate plus the lifting, the chain laws for
  lteb/dLte/fateLte, and the decidable preorder on grades.
- verification/proofs/lean4/ratified-order/RatifiedOrder.lean (new):
  Lean 4.16.0, core only, no simp/omega/decide; the same statements.
- TB/Bridge.agda (new): the values of fateLte, ▷f, bondLte, ▷b,
  mergeLte and ▷m on a fixed sample, as numeral lists. The Rocq and Lean
  files state the same six literals about their own restatements. Bond
  and Merge are covered exhaustively, Fate on nine points (81 pairs).
  A restated definition that drifts from the Agda now fails its own
  kernel, even when every theorem about it still proves.
- scripts/check-recheck-legs.sh (new): pinned version asserted, compile,
  axiom audit over every declaration (fails on any axiom and on an empty
  audit domain), and six planted controls that must each be caught.
- proofs.yml: a recheck-legs job runs all three modes in CI.

Local results (this container):
  check-recheck-legs.sh rocq      PASS, 49 of 49 closed under the
                                  global context (coqc 8.18.0)
  check-recheck-legs.sh lean      PASS, no axioms for 49 of 49 declared
                                  theorems (Lean 4.16.0, 128a1e6b0a82)
  check-recheck-legs.sh controls  PASS, 6 of 6 caught; the drift
                                  control fails only at bridge_bcomp
  agda All.agda / Smoke.agda      exit 0 (Agda 2.7.0.1, stdlib v2.0)
  test-gate-falsifiability.sh     29/29; pwg-check.sh PASS
  shellcheck 0.11.0 (pinned)      clean over all tracked *.sh

The ledger is not changed here. Its legs and receipts follow once CI
has run on this commit, so no grade cites a receipt that does not exist.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01J4QvDf73vaDJwGZ3qMSeH3
The proofs and CI lane landed in the two commits before this one. This
commit records the evidence CI produced for them, in run 44006871652 on
d5234b1: Agda Theorem B PASS, and Recheck legs PASS (Rocq 49/49 closed,
Lean 49/49 axiom-free, 6/6 controls caught).

Ledger (verification/pwg.json):
- New receipts: agda-d5234b1, rocq-ratified-order-d5234b1,
  lean-ratified-order-d5234b1. Each records its checker version,
  invocation, inputs digest, observed output and axioms (none).
- L4-bond-merge, L4-lifting, A2-chain, retention-order: their Agda legs
  become PROVEN / AGDA-VERIFIED, citing the TB.Monotone and TB.OrderLaws
  declarations.
- All seven L4-*, A2-* and retention-order rows gain Rocq and Lean legs:
  re-proved, PROVEN, RECONCILED.

Derived, not written: all seven rows reach PWG-2ii. Census of 28 theory
obligations: PWG-3 15, PWG-2i 0, PWG-2ii 7, PWG-1 0, ungraded 6 (was
PWG-3 18, ungraded 10). None reaches PWG-1, because the receipts are not
at the ledger's source commit.

PROOF-STATUS: the derived table and census; the L4, A2 and retention
rows; rewritten census prose; and a §2.2 record for the new legs (route,
reason for re-proof, statement correspondence with the definition
bridge, residual assumptions: none, and the controls). README and
CHANGELOG follow.

Put to the owner, not absorbed: the 2026-11-09 ruling says "Lean is a
generator, not a leg", and its reason is the Mathlib dependency. These
Lean legs import nothing. They are recorded RECONCILED and they count.
If the ruling is meant to cover them too, their state becomes
BRIDGE-PENDING and the seven rows derive PWG-2i.

Gates: pwg-check PASS (table and census match), falsifiability 29/29,
aspect tests PASS=3, ledger JCS-canonical, asciidoctor 2.0.20 renders
PROOF-STATUS, README and CHANGELOG with no warning.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01J4QvDf73vaDJwGZ3qMSeH3
@sonarqubecloud

Copy link
Copy Markdown

@github-actions

Copy link
Copy Markdown

Fork governance

Lane Status Run
DEED syntax (repo deed) 🟢 conformant run 44008458735
K9-DEED conformance (L0–L2; L3 not verified) 🟡 conformant (advisory debt) (job: success) same run
Hypatia verdict grid 🟡 medium findings (job: success) · advisory in grid scope: 🔴 red (0 critical, 9 high, not grading) same run

Scope: the three lanes below are static checks at the named commit. A
green row means every applicable check in its declared scope passed;
orange means evidence is missing, not that nothing was found. The
Hypatia verdict covers GATING rows only; advisory reporters are listed
in its grid and their severity counts are limited to the grid scope.
A blocking gate may inspect findings outside the delta grid’s grade; open
the linked run and check annotations for the failing step and, where
applicable, the finding. No row is a security certification.

K9-DEED conformance

k9-deed L0–L2 yellow

🟡 advisory · commit 131a33c6c1c3 · run 44008458735 · validator hyperpolymath/standards@857ff096af11

Category Status Pass Fail Indeterminate N/A Since previous revision
K9 contract typecheck 🟢 conformant 1 0 0 0 — no comparable baseline
K9 validator self-test 🟢 conformant 49 0 0 0 — no comparable baseline
K9 live corpus (L0–L2) 🟡 advisory 2 8 (8 advisory) 0 0 — no comparable baseline
K9 live corpus (L0–L2): 8 finding(s) / scope notes
  • .machine_readable/self-validating/examples/setup-repo.k9.ncl — fail (advisory): K9-S007: security flags request capabilities the grant does not cover: net.fetch fs.write process.spawn (default-deny: list them in pedigree.security.capabilities); K9-S009: leash is 'Hunt but no pedigree.signature block is present (presence required here; verificatio
  • .machine_readable/self-validating/methodology-guard.k9.ncl — fail (advisory): K9-S002: pedigree.schema_version is missing; K9-S003: pedigree.component_type is missing (required by contract v1.0.0 §6.2); K9-N001: component violates the K9.Component contract: error: missing definition for `schema_version` ┌─ /home/runner/work/
  • .machine_readable/self-validating/template-hunt.k9.ncl — fail (advisory): K9-S003: pedigree.component_type is an unfilled placeholder: 'TODO: describe component type (e.g., 'deployment', 'setup-script')'; K9-S005: pedigree.metadata.name is an unfilled placeholder: 'TODO: component-name'; K9-S007: security flags request capabilities the gran
  • .machine_readable/self-validating/template-kennel.k9.ncl — fail (advisory): K9-S003: pedigree.component_type is an unfilled placeholder: 'TODO: describe component type (e.g., 'build-config', 'metadata')'; K9-S005: pedigree.metadata.name is an unfilled placeholder: 'TODO: component-name'
  • .machine_readable/self-validating/template-yard.k9.ncl — fail (advisory): K9-S003: pedigree.component_type is an unfilled placeholder: 'TODO: describe component type (e.g., 'validated-config', 'schema')'; K9-S005: pedigree.metadata.name is an unfilled placeholder: 'TODO: component-name'
  • container/deploy.k9.ncl — fail (advisory): K9-S002: pedigree.schema_version is missing; K9-S003: pedigree.component_type is missing (required by contract v1.0.0 §6.2); K9-S004: pedigree.security.leash is missing; K9-S005: pedigree.metadata.name is missing; K9-S011: component declares a 'recipes' block at l
  • coordination.k9 — fail (advisory): K9-S002: pedigree.schema_version is missing; K9-S003: pedigree.component_type is missing (required by contract v1.0.0 §6.2); K9-N001: component does not typecheck against K9.Component: error: unexpected token ┌─ /home/runner/work/trope-checker/trope-checker/.k9-
  • session/custom-checks.k9 — fail (advisory): K9-S002: pedigree.schema_version is missing; K9-S003: pedigree.component_type is missing (required by contract v1.0.0 §6.2); K9-N001: component does not typecheck against K9.Component: error: unexpected token ┌─ /home/runner/work/trope-checker/trope-checker/sess

Scope: K9 components L0–L2 against contract v1.0.0 at the named standards commit. L3 signature verification and routed coordination-dialect files are not certified. Green is limited to this scope. Orange is missing evidence; yellow is grandfathered debt or warnings; grey is an explicit scope exclusion. report.json, badge.json and the validator logs are in the k9-grid artifact on the linked run.

Hypatia verdict grid

Hypatia grid yellow

🟡 medium · commit 131a33c6c1c3 · run 44008458735 · scope: this change (14 file(s))

Advisory: 11 row(s), worst 🔴 high (0 critical, 9 high in grid scope) — reported, never grading the change.

Unique graded findings across gating and advisory rows: 25 (25 reporter observations; 21 without sufficient identity to corroborate). Row counts remain per reporter; unique totals do not change gating.
Raw Hypatia alert-derived observations: 43 (code-scanning, Dependabot and secret-scanning; some may also be in SARIF; not an extra total).

Reporter Gate Status Critical High Medium Minor Since previous revision
Hypatia scan gating 🟡 medium 0 0 1 0 — no comparable baseline (no prior PR grid or unreadable snapshot)
panic-attack assail advisory 🟢 clean 0 0 0 0 — no comparable baseline (no prior PR grid or unreadable snapshot)
pons asinorum advisory 🟢 clean 0 0 0 0 — no comparable baseline (no prior PR grid or unreadable snapshot)
echidnabot advisory ⚪ not applicable 0 0 0 0 — no comparable baseline (no prior PR grid or unreadable snapshot)
rhodibot (RSR compliance) advisory 🟢 clean 0 0 0 0 — no comparable baseline (no prior PR grid or unreadable snapshot)
panicbot advisory ⚪ not applicable 0 0 0 0 — no comparable baseline (no prior PR grid or unreadable snapshot)
sustainabot advisory ⚪ not applicable 0 0 0 0 — no comparable baseline (no prior PR grid or unreadable snapshot)
glambot (presentation quality) advisory 🔵 minor 0 0 0 8 — no comparable baseline (no prior PR grid or unreadable snapshot)
seambot advisory ⚪ not applicable 0 0 0 0 — no comparable baseline (no prior PR grid or unreadable snapshot)
finishingbot (release readiness) advisory 🔴 high 0 9 5 2 — no comparable baseline (no prior PR grid or unreadable snapshot)
cipherbot advisory ⚪ not applicable 0 0 0 0 — no comparable baseline (no prior PR grid or unreadable snapshot)
accessibilitybot advisory ⚪ not applicable 0 0 0 0 — no comparable baseline (no prior PR grid or unreadable snapshot)
Hypatia scan: 13 finding(s)
  • medium research_extensions/RE005 — .github/workflows/proofs.yml:175 — workflow .github/workflows/proofs.yml:175 step `Typecheck Theorem B` swallows non-zero exit via `|| true` — failures will be masked
  • 12 further finding(s) in files this change does not touch: reported, not graded (0 critical, 0 high).
panic-attack assail: 3 finding(s)
  • 3 further finding(s) in files this change does not touch: reported, not graded (0 critical, 0 high).
echidnabot: not_applicable — proofs here are gated by their own toolchains (proofs.yml: Idris2, Lean, Agda); no ECHIDNA engine is configured, so this adapter could only ever report not_run
  • ⚪ not applicable: proofs here are gated by their own toolchains (proofs.yml: Idris2, Lean, Agda); no ECHIDNA engine is configured, so this adapter could only ever report not_run
rhodibot (RSR compliance): 11 finding(s)
  • 11 further finding(s) in files this change does not touch: reported, not graded (0 critical, 11 high).
panicbot: not_applicable — panic-attack already reports directly as its own row in the Hypatia verdict grid; enrolling panicbot would count the same findings twice
  • ⚪ not applicable: panic-attack already reports directly as its own row in the Hypatia verdict grid; enrolling panicbot would count the same findings twice
sustainabot: not_applicable — reserved fleet slot; no adapter exists (gitbot-fleet README)
  • ⚪ not applicable: reserved fleet slot; no adapter exists (gitbot-fleet README)
glambot (presentation quality): 82 finding(s)
  • info GS-001 — Install git-seo for comprehensive SEO analysis: https://github.com/hyperpolymath/git-seo
  • info MACH-007 — ECOSYSTEM.scm not found in .machine_readable/ directory.
  • info MACH-007 — META.scm not found in .machine_readable/ directory.
  • info MACH-007 — STATE.scm not found in .machine_readable/ directory.
  • info MACH-005 — No robots.txt found. Consider adding one for crawler control.
  • info VIS-005 — docs/status/PROOF-STATUS.adoc:1 — Line 97 characters exceeds max length of 80.
  • info VIS-005 — CHANGELOG.adoc:17 — Line 82 characters exceeds max length of 80.
  • info VIS-005 — README.adoc:1 — Line 97 characters exceeds max length of 80.
  • 74 further finding(s) in files this change does not touch: reported, not graded (0 critical, 2 high).
seambot: not_applicable — no seam register is declared (spec/seams/seam-register.json)
  • ⚪ not applicable: no seam register is declared (spec/seams/seam-register.json)
finishingbot (release readiness): 127 finding(s)
  • high V1-DOC-ROADMAP.adoc — Required file ROADMAP.adoc not found (Project roadmap).
  • high TOOL-001 — .tool-versions file not found for asdf/mise version management.
  • high SCM-001-NEUROSYM.scm — Required SCM file NEUROSYM.scm not found (Neurosymbolic AI documentation).
  • high SCM-001-AGENTIC.scm — Required SCM file AGENTIC.scm not found (Agentic AI integration documentation).
  • high SCM-001-PLAYBOOK.scm — Required SCM file PLAYBOOK.scm not found (Operational playbooks and procedures).
  • high SCM-001-ECOSYSTEM.scm — Required SCM file ECOSYSTEM.scm not found (Project's place in the ecosystem).
  • high SCM-001-META.scm — Required SCM file META.scm not found (Meta-level information and architectural decisions).
  • high SCM-001-STATE.scm — Required SCM file STATE.scm not found (Project state and progress tracking).
  • high PH-100 — Found 102 placeholders, exceeds maximum allowed (0)
  • medium V1-COM-CONTRIBUTING.md — CONTRIBUTING.md file not found (Contribution guidelines).
  • medium V1-COM-CODE_OF_CONDUCT.md — CODE_OF_CONDUCT.md file not found (Code of conduct).
  • medium V1-SEC-001 — SECURITY.md not found for responsible disclosure.
  • medium TEST-AG-002 — No direct single-line Agda source check was identified in the known workflow or recipe locations. Dynamic runners need separate review; no proof was executed.
  • medium CLM-006 — docs/status/PROOF-STATUS.adoc — Documentation references non-existent file: lakefile.toml
  • info CLM-003 — README.adoc — README missing 'Usage examples' section
  • info CLM-003 — README.adoc — README missing 'Installation instructions' section
  • 111 further finding(s) in files this change does not touch: reported, not graded (0 critical, 1 high).
cipherbot: not_applicable — no cryptography is implemented in this repository; the hashes present are checksum/integrity pins, which cipherbot would report as cryptographic findings
  • ⚪ not applicable: no cryptography is implemented in this repository; the hashes present are checksum/integrity pins, which cipherbot would report as cryptographic findings
accessibilitybot: not_applicable — no served HTML surface; this is a checker library/CLI with AsciiDoc documentation
  • ⚪ not applicable: no served HTML surface; this is a checker library/CLI with AsciiDoc documentation

Scope: static findings reported by each row's tool at the named commit. The table grades only findings in files this change touches, so the colour answers "does this change introduce anything?", not "what does the whole repository still carry?". Standing findings are counted in each accordion and in report.json; the baseline filter remains the place where acknowledged debt is recorded. The lane state is the worst GATING row; advisory rows are listed and counted but never set it. Purple, red, yellow and blue grade the worst GRADED finding present; orange is evidence missing, malformed or a scanner that did not run; grey is an explicit scope exclusion with its reason. No row is a security certification. report.json, badge.json and the raw findings are in the verdict-grid artifact on the linked run.

@hyperpolymath
hyperpolymath marked this pull request as ready for review November 17, 2026 04:34
Repository owner deleted a comment from coderabbitai Bot Nov 17, 2026
Repository owner deleted a comment from chatgpt-codex-connector Bot Nov 17, 2026
Repository owner deleted a comment from chatgpt-codex-connector Bot Nov 17, 2026
@hyperpolymath
hyperpolymath merged commit c5c5147 into claude/pwg-names-ladder Nov 17, 2026
42 checks passed
@hyperpolymath
hyperpolymath deleted the claude/prove-l4-a2-full branch November 17, 2026 04:51
hyperpolymath pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Nov 17, 2026
…sibond

Brings in #122 (L4 in full and A2 proved in Agda, rechecked in Rocq and
core Lean), which merged into #119's branch after this branch had taken
#123. The merge is textually clean.

Checked on the merged tree, because #123 tightened what a grade may
stand on and #122 added receipts under the older rules:

  scripts/pwg-check.sh               PASS, table and census match
  scripts/pwg-derive.sh --census     PWG-3 15, PWG-2ii 7, ungraded 6 of 28
  scripts/test-gate-falsifiability   43/43
  tests/aspect_tests.sh              PASS

The census is the one #122 published. Its three new receipts report no
axioms, so the disposition rule admits them, and its Agda receipt
records the canonical invocation for both entrypoints.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5.2 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01J4QvDim4mMEfCer9SiAV4H
hyperpolymath added a commit that referenced this pull request Nov 17, 2026
## Summary

This is a follow-up to #122, which merged into this base. Before #122
merged, the owner chose **"Count it + amend ADR 0005 D4"** in the
selector. That decision settles whether a Lean recheck leg with no
Mathlib may count, given the 2026-11-09 ruling "Lean is a generator, not
a leg". This PR writes the decision into ADR 0005, so the ADR and
PROOF-POLICY §2 stop disagreeing on paper.

**No grade moves.** The ledger already followed this ruling. The census
is unchanged: of 28, `PWG-3` 15, `PWG-2ii` 7, `ungraded` 6.

## Changes

- **ADR 0005**: an amendment section dated 2026-11-17.
- It records both rulings. On 2026-11-09: Lean with Mathlib is a
generator, never a leg. On 2026-11-17: theory is rechecked in Rocq and
Lean with no Mathlib, and a Lean leg that imports nothing is a §2
recheck leg.
- **D4 as amended** gives a role table: Agda is the normative kernel;
Rocq is a recheck leg; core Lean is a recheck leg; Lean with Mathlib is
a generator; Idris2 is the reference; Rust is the fast core. The table
notes that core Lean does not earn §8.3's `+foundation-diverse` tag.
- **D5 as amended**: the template removal stands. The 2026-11-17 Rocq
file is an instantiated, gated recheck leg, so the repository has four
proof developments, not three.
- It names the out-of-scope upkeep: `just proof-status` and the other D5
recipes still say "three provers" (doctrine 16).
- **PROOF-STATUS, README, CHANGELOG**: the "put to the owner" wording
from #122 is replaced with the ruling and a pointer to the amendment.

## RSR Quality Checklist

### Required

- [x] Tests pass: `pwg-check.sh` PASS, with table and census unchanged
- [x] Code is formatted (docs only)
- [x] Linter is clean: asciidoctor 2.0.20 with `--failure-level=WARN` on
all four files
- [x] No banned language patterns
- [x] No `unsafe` blocks without `// SAFETY:` comments
- [x] No banned functions
- [x] SPDX license headers present (unchanged)
- [x] No secrets, credentials, or `.env` files included

### As Applicable

- [x] `docs/decisions/` updated
- [x] Documentation updated
- [x] `CHANGELOG` updated

## Testing

```
bash scripts/pwg-check.sh   -> PASS ... 29 obligation(s) derived, published table and census match
asciidoctor -o /dev/null --failure-level=WARN <each of the 4 files>   -> exit 0
```

No proof file changed, so no kernel run is needed or claimed.

---
_Generated by [Claude
Code](https://claude.ai/code/session_01J4QvDf73vaDJwGZ3qMSeH3)_

Co-authored-by: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants